Top 5 challenges with deploying containers in production

on Feb 24, 2017

 

Docker containers make app development easier. But deploying them in production can be hard.

Software developers are typically focused on a single application, application stack or workload that they need to run on a specific infrastructure. In production, however, a diverse set of applications run on a variety of technology (e.g. Java, LAMP, etc.), which need to be deployed on heterogeneous infrastructure running on-premises, in the cloud or both. This gives rise to several challenges with running containerized applications in production:

  1. Controlling the complexity of extremely dense, fast changing environments
  2. Taking maximum advantage of a highly volatile technology ecosystem
  3. Ensuring developers have the freedom to innovate
  4. Deploying containers across disparate, distributed infrastructure
  5. Enforcing organizational policy and controls

Controlling the complexity of extremely dense, fast changing environments

According to the June 2016 Cloud Foundry “Hope Versus Reality: Containers in 2016” report, 45 percent of survey respondents said their biggest deployment worry is that Docker is too complex to integrate into their environments.[1] A big reason for this is the density and volatility of containerized environments.  Because operating systems and kernels do not need to be loaded for each container, containerized environments enable better workload density within a given amount of infrastructure than more traditional virtualized environments. As a result, the total volume of components that need to be created, monitored and destroyed across the production environment is exponentially larger, significantly increasing the complexity of managing container-based environments.

Not only are there more things to be managed, but they are also changing faster than ever before.  A Datadog survey shows that, while traditional and cloud-based VMs have an average lifespan of almost 15 days, Docker containers have an average lifespan of 2.5 days.[2] The result is an order-of-magnitude increase in the number of things that need to be individually managed and monitored.

The complexity of these dense, fast-changing environments is further compounded by the complexity of the architecture. Containers are typically deployed over highly distributed environments; on a single cluster or on a multi-cluster environment.  The makeup of these clusters is highly disparate and they may be located on-premises, in the cloud or some combination of the two.  While 60% of containers run on Amazon Web Services (AWS), 40% continue to run on-premises.[3]

Organizations therefore need an easier approach to orchestrate containers and manage the underlying infrastructure services for multi-container, multi-host applications.  This is particularly important for applications with a microservices architecture, such as a web application that consists of a container cluster running web servers to host multiple instances of the frontend (for failover and load balancing), as well as multiple backend services each running in separate containers.

Taking advantage of a highly volatile technology ecosystem

The Docker ecosystem is very volatile and complex.  Over the past few years a flurry of third-party tools and services have emerged to help developers deploy, configure and manage their containerized workflows as they move from development to production.  Because they are based on open source technologies, the rate at which these tools and services change and the volume of new documentation makes it very challenging to put together a stable technology stack to run containers in production.  It also makes it hard for companies to build and maintain the engineering skills needed to take advantage of the rich ecosystem.  According to RightScale’s fifth annual State of the Cloud Survey, for companies who are not currently using containers, lack of experience was by far the top challenge (39 percent) for container adoption.[4]

Ensuring developers have the freedom to innovate

In simplifying container management, it’s important not to lose the flexibility developers require to innovate.  They need to be able to pick and choose the tools and frameworks they want to use when they need them. RedMonk refers to this as the “era of permissionless development”.[5] When asked to solve a problem, most developers no longer ask what tools they can use, they look for the best tool for the job. They also prefer to use the most recent releases, which isn’t necessarily the most stable version, so they can quickly take advantage of any new capabilities.  However, they are also increasingly being required to take responsibility for ensuring that any application logic they create runs in production and quickly fixing it if it does not. This means that they also need to be able to roll back a deployment if they run into issues.

Developers require the freedom of root access and they want to be able to install any open source software they like.  This is why they typically avoid traditional platform as a service (PaaS) solutions. PaaS abstracts away containers, so developers can focus on coding instead of managing containers. However, they are also proprietary and are not as versatile as a home-grown open source stacks.  They constrain the developers’ ability to innovate by locking them into one vendor or infrastructure provider.

Deploying containers across disparate, distributed infrastructure

One of the primary benefits of containers is that they are portable—an application and all its dependencies can be bundled into a single container, which is independent from the host version of Linux kernel, platform distribution or deployment model. This container can be transferred to another host running Docker and executed without compatibility issues. Infrastructure services vary dramatically between clouds and data centers, however, making real application portability almost impossible without architecting around those differences in the application. Using containers to make applications portable across diverse infrastructure therefore requires more than just a standardized unit for shipping code.  It requires infrastructure services, which include:

  1. Hosts (CPU, memory, storage and network connectivity) running Docker containers, including virtual machines or physical machines running on-premises as well as on the cloud
  2. A network that enables containers on different hosts to communicate with each other using either coordinated port mappings or software defined networking
  3. Load balancers to expose services to the Internet
  4. DNS, which is commonly used to implement service discovery
  5. Integrated health checks ensure only healthy containers are used to serve requests
  6. A way to perform actions triggered by certain events, such as restarting new containers after a host fails, ensuring a fixed number of healthy containers are available or ensuring new hosts and containers are created in response to increased load
  7. A way to scale services by creating new containers from existing containers
  8. Storage snapshot and backup for backing up a stateful container for disaster recovery purposes

Once these infrastructure services are deployed, organizations can be challenged with monitoring them. DevOps teams need to easily troubleshoot issues.  Monitoring and logging infrastructure performance, and alerting DevOps teams to any issues is therefore an important capability of any container management solution.

Enforcing organization policy and controls

There are security and compliance concerns related to deploying containers that must be addressed for larger enterprises to use them in production, particularly those in regulated industries such as finance and healthcare. Companies such as Docker have continued to push for fixes and create new software and integration across the toolchain to cope with that problem.

However, there is still a lack of parity between application container security and what enterprises are used to with virtual machines. This includes enforcing organizational policy and ensuring secure access to the containers and cluster administration, including managing certificates for transport layer security (TLS). Users and groups need to be able to share or deny access to resources and environments (e.g. development or production) via role-based access control (RBAC).  User authentication requires integration with Active Directory, LDAP and/or GitHub.

Rancher container management platform can help

Containers make software development easier, enabling you to write code faster and run it better.  However, running containers in production can be hard. There are a wide variety of technologies to integrate and manage, and new tools are emerging every day.  Rancher makes it easy for you to manage all aspects of running containers.  You no longer need to develop the technical skills required to integrate a complex set of open source technologies.

Don’t just take our word for it, check out what SpareFoot has to say about Rancher.

Rancher includes everything you need to make Docker work in production on any infrastructure.  A portable layer of infrastructure services is easily configured and integrated. An easy to use user interface enables you to take advantage of a rich set orchestration features and then deploy your containers with a single click.  The robust application catalog makes it simple to package configuration files as templates and share them across your organization. With over 20 million downloads and enterprise-class support, Rancher has quickly become the open source platform of choice for running containers in production.

 It’s easy to get started with Rancher.

Just follow these steps:

1.  Try it out – You can now try Rancher using the Rancher Sandbox. It’s publicly hosted and always up to date.

2. Download – Rancher is deployed as a Docker container and easy to deploy on your cluster or even your laptop.

3.  Get started – Deploying Rancher takes less than 5 minutes if you follow the steps in the quick start guide.

4.  Use the docs – Rancher is incredibly easy to use.  However, there’s a wealth of information in the technical documents in case you need it.

5.   Take advantage of our awesome community of users – The forums are the best place to hear about the latest product releases as well as interact with your peers and Rancher engineers.

Resources:

[1] https://www.cloudfoundry.org/hope-versus-reality-containers-in-2016/
[2] https://www.datadoghq.com/docker-adoption/
[3] https://clusterhq.com/assets/pdfs/state-of-container-usage-june-2016.pdf
[4] http://www.rightscale.com/blog/cloud-industry-insights/new-devops-trends-2016-state-cloud-survey
[5] http://redmonk.com/fryan/2016/02/16/docker-containers-and-the-cio/
Free Online Training

Want a crash course in using Rancher?

Join us for free online training courses, hosted monthly by a Rancher technical expert. We provide a great hands-on overview for new users setting up a Rancher deployment, and answer any and all questions you have about Rancher and how to integrate it into your DevOps processes!

Sign up

Recent Posts


Upcoming Events